August 6, 2010

Truck Mechanic Settles Lawsuit Against Trucking Companies and Railroad

A recent Cook County work site injury lawsuit was settled for $3.375 million; Ortiz v. Cato Karabegovic, et al., No. 06 L 006651. Contributing to the settlement were two trucking companies, a truck driver, and a railroad company.

Tool%20Belt%20A%201.jpgThe plaintiff, Ortiz, was a mechanic working at a railroad yard on Chicago's South Side. While working on the defendant Karabegovic's truck, Ortiz was severely injured after being dragged for 30 feet underneath the moving truck. As a result of this incident, Ortiz sustained multiple fractures and severe nerve damage to his leg, which left him with a permanent foot drop. The 33 year-old Ortiz is no longer able to work as a mechanic as a result of the injury

However, there was some debate regarding who was liable for the plaintiff's injury and to what degree the plaintiff contributed to his own accident. Issues of contributory fault are important in Illinois personal injury lawsuits because if the defense can prove that the plaintiff was more than 50% at fault then any judgment entered against the defense is reduced by the degree of plaintiff's negligence. For example, if a jury returned a $100,000 verdict but found that the plaintiff was 40% negligent, then the jury award would be reduced by 40%, leaving the plaintiff with $60,000.

Continue reading "Truck Mechanic Settles Lawsuit Against Trucking Companies and Railroad" »

February 17, 2010

Illinois Truck Driver Settles Rear End Crash

Oftentimes, when we think of life-changing truck accidents in Illinois, we think of rollovers or jack-knife accidents. However, a standard Illinois rear-end trucking accident can also lead to drastic changes to drivers' and passengers' lives. The case of the plaintiff truck driver in Shinaberry v. KA Bulk Transport d/b/a Klemm Tank Lines, et al., 06 C 5947, illustrates this point.

Speeding%20Truck%204.bmpIn Shinaberry, an out-of-state truck driver was struck by another truck in an Illinois rear-end trucking accident. The plaintiff was stopped at a red light when he was struck from behind by another Illinois truck. Following the accident plaintiff sustained some low back pain, which was initially diagnosed as a lumbar strain.

However, after the plaintiff's back pain continued he was referred for additional treatment. It was at this time that he was diagnosed with a lumbar disc bulge, lumbar stenosis, and S1 radiculopathy. At this point, the seemingly simple Illinois rear-end collision caused the plaintiff to undergo surgery to repair his injuries, including a spinal fusion. After the operation the plaintiff underwent some physical therapy to improve his mobility.

Continue reading "Illinois Truck Driver Settles Rear End Crash " »

February 10, 2010

Illinois Truck Accident Disables Chicago Brick Layer - Settlement Reached

A Chicago area brick layer settled his Cook County personal injury case with a semi-truck driver after his vehicle was struck by the defendant. It was alleged that the Cook County trucking accident occurred when defendant improperly took a left turn in front of the plaintiff’s vehicle when the defendant truck driver’s vision was obscured by the weather conditions and the way the roadway curved.

Trucks%204.jpgThe plaintiff suffered an acetabular fracture in the Cook County truck accident. The acetabulum is the socket part of the pelvic bone that connects the femur to the rest of the pelvis.

Recovery of such an injury can be long and difficult. Patients are often required to keep weight off their hip for up to three months. Long-term effects are also not uncommon. Patients commonly suffer from hip arthritis, and even need hip replacements later in their lives.

The plaintiff is now disabled and unable to return to his usual work. The Chicago trucking accident case was settled on the plaintiff's behalf for $2 million.

Continue reading "Illinois Truck Accident Disables Chicago Brick Layer - Settlement Reached" »

December 21, 2009

Illinois Truck Accident Insurance Coverage Clarified By Illinois Supreme Court

The final chapter of a long debate regarding whether the Illinois Vehicle Code's "omnibus coverage" applies to commercial truckers was recently decided upon by the Illinois Supreme Court. The Court's held in Zurich American Inc. Co. v. Key Cartage, Inc., No. 107472 (Oct 29, 2009) that Illinois commercial vehicles are covered under the Illinois Commercial Transportation Law, a statute governing commercial vehicles, and not the Illinois Vehicle Code. Therefore the omnibus coverage clause under the Illinois Vehicle Code does not apply to commercial vehicle insurance.

Jacknife%20truck%202.jpgThe Illinois Supreme Courts decision overturned the Illinois Appellate Court's previous decision in the Illinois trucking accident case which asserted that the Illinois Vehicle Code did in fact apply to commercial vehicles.

In Zurich, the issue at stake was whether Zurich, a company insuring a trucking company, or West Bend, an insurer covering the leased commercial vehicle, was responsible for providing coverage. The case facts were that Franklin Truck Group, insured by West Bend, had leased a vehicle to Rose Cartage Services, insured by Zurich. Rose Cartage loaned this vehicle out to an affiliated company, Key Cartage. One of Key Cartage's drivers was operating this truck when he was involved in an Illinois truck accident that left one dead.

Zurich's insurance policy had a reciprocal coverage provision that stated that they would only cover Rose Cartage employees and that they would not extend coverage to anyone using the truck with expressed or implied interest if that person did not also insure the vehicle's owner. In response, West Bend contended that this reciprocal coverage clause violated the Illinois Vehicle Code that requires insurance companies to provide "omnibus coverage", i.e. coverage to any driver that has the expressed or implied permission of the insured to use the vehicle.

Continue reading "Illinois Truck Accident Insurance Coverage Clarified By Illinois Supreme Court" »

December 7, 2009

Chicago Intersection Accident Settled Against Electric Company

A Chicago driver settled his Illinois personal injury case with an Illinois electric company after his van was struck by the defendant’s vehicle. The defendant had ran a red light at the Chicago intersection of W. Taylor St. and S. Clinton St., causing the Illinois trucking accident.

Spine%20xray%201.jpgThe operator of the van, the plaintiff, sustained cervical and lumbar spine damage that required multiple-level fusion surgery. The defendant who ran the red light at that intersection argued that the plaintiff’s injuries were due to a prior Illinois auto accident. However, this did not preclude his employer from settling the case and compensating the plaintiff for his injuries.

The electric company settled the case with the plaintiff for $2.1 million. However, according to the report of the settlement, there was a statutory lien on the case for $433,000. Because the plaintiff was working at the time he was entitled to and received Illinois workers’ compensation. The lien was waived, which was also reported in the settlement.

Continue reading "Chicago Intersection Accident Settled Against Electric Company" »

November 18, 2009

Cook County Trucking Accident Results in Wrongful Death Claim

A recent Cook County trucking accident settlement raises some interesting question about driver responsibility. The Cook County wrongful death lawsuit was brought by the family of a 47 year-old Illinois auto worker who was killed in a collision with a truck.

Trucks%203.jpgThe surviving truck driver was not fluent in English and admittedly could not read English. The truck driver therefore was unable to read highway signs warning drivers that an accident had occurred up ahead and advising them to slow down. The truck driver did not slow down and crashed into the rear end of the decedent's pick-up truck, which was then propelled forwarded and pinned against the median wall. The decedent was trapped in the vehicle as it ignited in flames.

The decedent's estate claimed that the truck driver was an employee of Ford Air, Inc. and that the company knew or should have know that the driver could not speak or read English. Federal law requires truck drivers to have enough knowledge of English to be able to converse with a police officer. The idea is that in the event of an accident those with commercial driving licenses should be able to provide details about the chain of events. The truck driver in this case clearly did not meet this federal standard, which the estate claimed contributed to the Cook County trucking accident.

Continue reading "Cook County Trucking Accident Results in Wrongful Death Claim" »

September 23, 2009

Illinois Truck Accident Settled by Truck Driver For $2 Million

Despite having a preexisting back condition, a plaintiff driver received $2 million from the defendant driver for a back injury sustained in an Illinois trucking accident. Prior to settlement, the Chicago personal injury case was pending in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.

Speeding%20Truck%203.bmpIn the 2004 truck accident, a box truck driven by the Illinois plaintiff was rear-ended by a tractor-trailer driven by the defendant. The defendant tractor-trailer driver admitted responsibility for the rear-end crash. Following the Illinois truck accident the plaintiff driver experienced significant back pain and eventually required a spinal fusion. However, despite the surgery he has been unable to return to work as an HVAC specialist since the accident due to the high level of pain and subsequent physical limitations.

It is actually fairly common for auto accidents to aggravate prior conditions to the point where they interfere with the victim's life, especially in rear-end accidents. In this case the plaintiff had a prior back condition that was aggravated by the collision and causing it to become symptomatic. So even though the plaintiff had no prior back pain, his underlying problems were already present at the time of the collision.

Continue reading "Illinois Truck Accident Settled by Truck Driver For $2 Million" »

September 11, 2009

Chicago Truck Crash Results in $25 Million Jury Award To Man Who Sustained Spinal Injury

A Cook County jury recently returned a verdict awarding over $25 million to an Illinois resident who suffered a severe spinal injury after being involved in a truck crash. The then 38 year-old plaintiff was left as an "incomplete paraplegic" and has been unable to return to work since the 2004 accident. The defendant driver was also left paralyzed after the truck accident.

Traffic%20Light%201.jpgThe Illinois truck accident occurred when the plaintiff's SUV collided with a truck being driven by an Illinois Department of Transportation (IDOT) employee. At the time the plaintiff was heading to a Schaumburg construction site when he collided with the IDOT driver at the intersection of Frontage Road and the Elgin-O'Hare Expressway. Both drivers alleged that they had a green light and that the other driver's signal was red. The local Illinois police attempted to reconstruct the Illinois truck accident, but were unable to determine which driver was at fault.

In cases like this accident reconstruction can be extremely difficult and oftentimes might not result in any definitive conclusions. Without witnesses who can testify as to which version of the events is correct it is hard to determine what happened. However, when there are other factors to consider, such as an intoxicated driver, or poor weather conditions, then the process becomes much easier.

Continue reading "Chicago Truck Crash Results in $25 Million Jury Award To Man Who Sustained Spinal Injury" »

June 10, 2009

Chicago Construction Site Accident Settled Leaving Laborer's Family With $4.5 Million

Now that the road construction season is upon us in Chicago and Illinois it is important to remember to drive safely and cautiously when in a construction zone. According to a Bureau of Labor Statistics study, between 1995 and 2002, almost 900 road construction workers died from on the job injuries, with over half of those fatalities resulting from being struck by a vehicle.

Construction%20Sign%201.jpgHowever, a recent settlement in a Chicago construction injury case highlights that not only drivers and commuters need to be more careful, but that co-workers also need to practice on the job safety. The case in question involved a 21 year-old construction employee who had been assigned to dig trenches. After completing one trench and preparing to dig a second one, the worker was crushed when a truck driven by a fellow construction worker backed into him.

The decedent's surviving family members claimed that the driver of the construction truck was negligent and had received inadequate training for the specialized truck he was driving, which was a combination back hoe and end-loader. Furthermore, the family claimed that the construction company was also negligent for the work-related injury because they had not carefully supervised this driver to ensure that he operated the truck in a safe and proper manner.

The defendant, employer of the construction truck operator, claimed that the decedent was negligent in failing to keep a proper lookout for his safety. The decedent was survived by his wife and a two-month old son. The case was settled for $4.5 million after a mediation with a former Cook County Circuit judge.

Continue reading "Chicago Construction Site Accident Settled Leaving Laborer's Family With $4.5 Million" »

June 8, 2009

Investigating Illinois Truck Crashes Involving Commercial Vehicles

The Commercial Motor Vehicles Safety Act of 1986 (CMVSA) was passed by Congress to regulate interstate trucking. The CMVSA aimed to improve highway safety by making sure that all truck and bus drivers on the road are qualified to operate those vehicles. Prior to the passing of the CMVSA there was not any uniform testing or licensing standards for bus or truck drivers.

Accident%201.jpgIn order to increase the safety of its highways Illinois adopted portions of the CMVSA. However, despite these measures trucking accidents continue to occur. After a trucking crash takes place it is imperative to investigate the accident to determine its cause. A key part of this investigation involves preserving information and evidence that could provide helpful clues in evaluating the occurrence.

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSR) § 395.8 requires the driver to keep a complete record of his or her on/off-duty status at all times. And when a trucking accident has occurred, FMCSR § 395.8(k)(2) requires that truck drivers retain a copy of the on/off-duty status for the seven consecutive days prior to the accident.

In addition, the trucking companies are required by federal regulations to maintain all records and supporting documents regarding the status of each of its drivers for at least a six month period. In the case of an Illinois trucking accident these records can be obtained by making a written request.

Continue reading "Investigating Illinois Truck Crashes Involving Commercial Vehicles" »

May 19, 2009

Trucking Accidents and the Engine Control Module (ECM), a.k.a. the “Black Box”

There’s two sides to every story and trucking accidents are no different. Typically when two vehicles are involved in an accident the vehicle drivers' stories vary in some way. Law enforcement officials and insurance companies are left with the job of sorting through the facts to come up with an accurate picture of what happened, which is not an easy job.

Speeding%20Truck%202.bmpFortunately, when an accident involves a truck there is often an Engine Control Module (ECM), commonly known as a black box, to help establish what happened during the trucking accident. The data stored on the black box can be downloaded to serve as undisputed evidence of the crash events.

Most truck tractor manufacturers put some sort of ECM in the tractor to monitor the engine performance and various driver variables. How the data can be obtained from the black box varies by model, but typically the computer records all incidents of hard brake, engine revolutions, and if the truck's clutch was engaged. Newer tractors may also be equipped with devices to monitor driver fatigue and to assist in avoiding rollover prevention. ECMs may also keep track of all vehicles driving ahead of the tractor and those driving in the truck's blind spot. All of this information can prove invaluable when investigating an Illinois trucking accident.

Continue reading "Trucking Accidents and the Engine Control Module (ECM), a.k.a. the “Black Box”" »

May 12, 2009

Cellphone Use While Driving Leads to Increased Car Accidents and Trucking Accidents

Last summer on Missouri Highway 40, an Alabama trucker plowed into stopped traffic on Highway 40 in St. Louis County killing 3 people. He is now being held at the St. Louis County jail in Clayton, MO after being charged with three counts of involuntary manslaughter as a result of the truck accident.

Cellphone%201.jpgThe truck driver was behind the wheel of a 2005 Freightliner loaded with scrap aluminum. According to reports the truck driver was on his cell phone at the time of the incident. Apparently the truck driver was distracted by his cell phone when he ran into and over a line of ten vehicles that were backed up on eastbound Highway 40 West of Interstate 270 in St. Louis County.

The Missouri Highway Patrol report indicates that the driver admitted to an investigator that he was distracted by his cell phone use at the time of the truck crash. Two of the crash victims were from Northeastern Missouri who were headed to a funeral in Tennessee.

The Missouri trucking accident raises the question of whether or not cell phones should be allowed on the road, an issue that has been debated every since cell phones became so popular.

Continue reading "Cellphone Use While Driving Leads to Increased Car Accidents and Trucking Accidents" »

May 6, 2009

Illinois Cracks Down on Truck Driver Licensing to Reduce Truck Accidents and Improve Trucking Safety

New reports show that even licensed truck drivers and bus drivers in Illinois may be unqualified to drive their respective vehicles because of inadequate testing in other states. Some of these unqualified drivers are threats to the public utilizing Illinois highways and can even lead to tragic trucking accidents and bus accidents. In fact, a link has been found between unskilled drivers and an increase in Illinois trucking accidents.

Speeding%20Truck%201.bmpThe Commercial Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1986 (CMVSA) was designed to stop these abuses by prohibiting drivers from holding more than one state license. The CMVSA is addressing the problems caused by unqualified truck drivers and bus drivers by creating a nationwide system that prevents the issuance of multiple licenses.

The CMVSA is also cracking down on the past practice among some unqualified drivers who had multiple licenses from different states to spread around their traffic convictions using different licenses from different states. A new system allows states to exchange information on traffic violations, making it easier to remove problem drivers from the road. In addition, truck drivers who violate the law are subject to tougher penalties.

Continue reading "Illinois Cracks Down on Truck Driver Licensing to Reduce Truck Accidents and Improve Trucking Safety" »

May 1, 2009

Illinois Trucking Accidents Linked to Unskilled Truckers

Trucking accidents in Illinois linked to unskilled truckers have spiraled upward in the last several years, which is in part a result of many unskilled truck drivers have actually receiving their trucking licenses fraudulently.

Semi%201.pngIn the last five years, the US government has uncovered licensing fraud in 24 states, including Illinois. Thousands of truck drivers nationwide have received licenses under suspicious circumstances. One licensing scheme involves third-party examiners who the state hires to perform the driver testing for truckers.

An Illinois trucking license scandal helped shed some light on the widespread problem of fraudulent driver’s licenses. A federal judge in Chicago remarked during a license fraud case that some of these truckers can be likened to “10-ton torpedoes”.

The judge’s comments came in a case related to a federal and state investigation launched 8 years ago in Illinois involving the sale of trucker’s driver’s licenses that led to the conviction of former Governor George Ryan on federal corruption charges. It was discovered that trucking licenses in Illinois were essentially for sale regardless of results on driving exams. That probe showed that unskilled truck drivers on Illinois highways lead to at least the deaths of 9 individuals.

Continue reading "Illinois Trucking Accidents Linked to Unskilled Truckers" »

March 4, 2009

Car, SUV And Truck Rollover Accidents No Longer Being Ignored By Manufacturers

Car and truck manufacturers have largely ignored the product defects causing insufficient occupant protection and rollover crashes until recently, relying instead on inadequate minimum government standards. However, this is changing in light of increased pressure from a consumer-friendly government coupled with years of having to compensate victims of rollover deaths and personal injuries. These manufacturers are now taking steps to protect the public.

Car%20Roof%201.jpgIn 2005, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) proposed an upgrade to the 1973 version of the federal roof crush standard for automobile manufacturers. At that time, the standard was so weak that most occupants in a rollover would be severely injured or killed. That standard merely requires a vehicle roof resist a static force of 1.5 times the empty weight of the vehicle or 5,000 lbs., whichever is less. This kind of standard does not reflect the dynamic forces that a vehicle typically experiences in an actual rollover. In virtually every rollover, the roof makes contact with the ground on one side or then the other.

Continue reading "Car, SUV And Truck Rollover Accidents No Longer Being Ignored By Manufacturers" »

February 23, 2009

Passenger Bus Crashes Increase In Frequency As Safety Issues Arise

Evidence shows that bus passengers in Illinois and nationwide run a higher risk today than in the past. Whether due to poor oversight, poor bus design, maintenance problems, or inattentive operators, the level of safety on the average commercial bus is far from what it should be. If these issues are not corrected then there will be a continued rise in the number of injured and killed passengers and tragic bus crashes.

Bus%201.jpgOne way to stem the increase in passenger injuries and deaths could be an increase or stricter enforcement of regulations in place to protect the traveling public. Poor reinforcement of the current regulatory structure has resulted in an environment where a bus company and its drivers operate freely without any fear of consequence.

Another measure is to increase safety features. Research has proven again and again that an increase in safety features can increase survivability in bus crashes. Yet commercial buses are not nearly as safe as they should be. Unlike safety measures taken in airplanes or cars, advances in passenger safety on buses have been slow. There are many ways to make buses safer.

For example, seat belts have been standard on both airplanes and automobiles, but not on buses. Incredibly most buses are not even equipped with seat belts.

Buses could also be made more crash worthy. The strength of a bus roof depends on its support structure. The pillars between the windows of the bus are critical. The bus manufacturers have enlarged their vehicles’ windows for the convenience of passengers, but the support structure for the roofs has been compromised.

Continue reading "Passenger Bus Crashes Increase In Frequency As Safety Issues Arise" »

February 2, 2009

Illinois Truck Accident Insurance Coverage Will Be Decided On By Illinois Supreme Court

In September 2008, a Illinois First District Appellate Court decision ordered Zurich American Insurance Company to cover a Illinois wrongful-death lawsuit against its insured Key Cartage and Terry Washington. Zurich American Insurance Co. v. Key Cartage, 2008 WL 4445122 (1st Dist., Sept. 30). The Illinois Supreme Court has agreed to hear this appeal in the case where Rose Services, an affiliate of Key Cartage, had leased the truck from Franklin Truck Group to haul waste.

Semi%20truck%201.jpgIt had been argued that Zurich should be obligated to provide co-primary insurance coverage because it issued a trucker’s insurance policy to Rose Services. Zurich argued that coverage was barred because a reciprocal coverage provision in its policy meant that unless it provided coverage to Franklin, Zurich was not obligated to provide coverage to Key.

The Illinois Appellate Court ruling, an issue of first impression, held that Zurich was required to provide omnibus coverage, which would extend the policy to any permissive driver of the truck. In their opinion the appellate court held that “[a]s a matter of public safety, Illinois public policy warrants mandatory omnibus coverage for commercial truckers that should not be limited by private agreement.”

Continue reading "Illinois Truck Accident Insurance Coverage Will Be Decided On By Illinois Supreme Court" »

January 23, 2009

Illinois Makes Mandatory Insurance Coverage For Vehicles Applicable to Truckers

Under the Illinois Vehicle Code, every motor vehicle liability policy issued in Illinois must cover drivers who have expressed or implied permission from the insured. Recently, in a question of first impression, the Illinois Appellate Court was asked whether this statutory requirement for omnibus coverage applies to a liability insurance policy issued to a trucking company for commercial vehicles.

Trucks%201.jpgBased on State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Universal Underwriters Group, 182 Ill.2d 240 (1998), the First District Court reversed a ruling for Zurich American Insurance Company and concluded that Zurich American was obligated to provide omnibus coverage under a trucker’s policy. Zurich American Insurance Co. v. Key Cartage, 2008 WL 4445122 (1st Dist., Sept. 30).

In this case, Zurich American had issued a trucker’s policy to Rose Cartage Services. One of the covered vehicles was a Kenworth tractor that Rose had leased from Franklin Truck Group and later loaned out to an affiliated company, Key Cartage.

Terry Washington was driving the vehicle for Key Cartage when it was involved in an Illinois truck accident that resulted in the other driver's death. Both Key Cartage and Washington were sued for the wrongful death of the individual. They argued that they were entitled to coverage under the policy that Zurich sold to Rose Cartage.

Continue reading "Illinois Makes Mandatory Insurance Coverage For Vehicles Applicable to Truckers" »

December 31, 2008

Is New Year's Eve The Most Dangerous Time of the Year to Be On the Road? What About for Pedestrians?

New%20Years%201.bmpNew Year's Eve is a time to celebrate the coming of 2009. Restaurants and bars in Chicago and nationwide are lively as many celebrate the holiday and the arrival of the new year with drinks and merriment. It is easy to imagine that New Year’s Eve is a risky time for drivers and pedestrians in Illinois and the rest of the states.

Holidays in general are the most hazardous times for drivers due to sharp increases in traveling and drunken driving. And when it comes to New Year’s Eve, research offers sobering statistics.

From 1986 to 2002, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has researched accident data in the United States, New Year's Day ranks fourth in terms of most accident-related fatalities on a given day. Coming in at first and second are the 4th and 3rd of July, followed by December 23rd. Based on these statistics New Year's Eve and Day are not the riskiest days of the year to be out celebrating.

Yet a closer examination of the statistics reveals something peculiar. While it might not be the deadliest day for those in vehicles, it is the deadliest day of the year for pedestrians. According to the IIHS study, New Year's edged out Halloween as the having the highest incidences of pedestrian deaths. On New Year's a large majority of these deaths can be attributed to the increase in drinking and celebrating. Half of the deaths involved alcohol impairment and 58% of the pedestrians who were killed had a high blood-alcohol concentration.

So this year when you are out celebrating the end of 2008 and the beginning of 2009, please remember to be safe and responsible. Happy New Year from the staff at Kreisman Law Offices.

Continue reading "Is New Year's Eve The Most Dangerous Time of the Year to Be On the Road? What About for Pedestrians?" »

November 14, 2008

Illinois Truck Accident: Driver Cleared In 'Unavoidable Accident'

Typically Illinois courts reward and protect an injured party. For example, if one party is negligent because they ran into a stopped car at a red light, then the injured driver would normally prevail at trial. But this is not the case when the negligent driver was part of an 'unavoidable accident'.

Garbage%20Truck%201.bmpA recent Illinois trucking accident case ruled in favor of the defendant truck driver on summary judgment (Coole v. Central Area Recycling, 2008 WL 2955543 (4th Dist., July 28)) . The facts of the case were such that the court determined there was an 'unavoidable accident' so the defendant was not at fault.

In Coole, the truck driver was driving 5 mph over the speed limit as he approached an intersection; there was no stop light or stop signs controlling his movement. At the same time the plaintiff was also approaching the same intersection. She had a stop sign, but rolled through it and was struck by the defendant truck driver who was going over the legal speed limit. The truck driver contended that he didn't have time to stop or avoid the broadside collision with Coole's vehicle. Coole died as a result of the collision and her father brought a wrongful death lawsuit against the truck driver.

Continue reading "Illinois Truck Accident: Driver Cleared In 'Unavoidable Accident'" »

November 11, 2008

Illinois Automobile Owner Responsible for Authorized Driver's Negligence

In Illinois and most other states when an automobile owner permits another person drive their car then the driver's negligence can be assigned to the vehicle's owner.

Hand%20Over%20Keys%201.jpgFor example, consider a Missouri case of Sam and his aunt Sandra [Back v. Winfield-Fire Protection Dist., No. SC 89001 (Mo. banc 2008)]. Sandra owns an automobile, but does not have a driving license, whereas her nephew, Sam, does. So when Sandra needs to go to a meeting she recruits Sam to drive her. On the way to her meeting Sam rear ended a fire truck that was partially parked in his lane with its emergency lights on.

As a result of the crash, his aunt was injured, and consequently sued her nephew and the fire protection district for negligence. Her nephew was dismissed after settling out of court with his aunt for $25,000. The case against the fire department continued on to trial, where the jury awarded $100,000 for her suffering. But because the jury found her to be 50% at fault in the accident, with the district also being 50% at fault, her damages were reduced by half.

The aunt appealed the reduction of her award by arguing that the trial court should not have instructed the jury that she could be held at fault because her nephew was negligent when he failed to keep a proper lookout. She felt that because she was a passenger she did not have a right to control it even though she owned the car.

Continue reading "Illinois Automobile Owner Responsible for Authorized Driver's Negligence" »

October 3, 2008

Truck Accident Leaves Illinois Teens Dead

When 16 year-old Illinois resident Hancock began making a left-hand turn at an intersection she did not see a tractor-trailer coming towards her. When the truck struck her car it was going approximately 10 m.p.h. over the speed limit. Hancock and her 16 year-old passenger were fatally injured in this Illinois trucking accident.

Jacknife%20truck%201.jpgAny time a car is involved in a truck accident the results can be disastrous, as they were here. No matter how safe and reliable your car is, when it's up against a tractor-trailer the odds are against you.

The teenagers' parents brought a claim against both the truck driver and his employer, alleging that he failed to obey the proper speed limit and had gone over his allotted hours of service that week according to federal law.

The defendants responded by filing an Illinois wrongful death claim with allegations that Hancock had not stopped at her stop sign, had not yielded to the right-of-way when making her turn, and did not have her headlights turned on. The defendants also denied that the truck driver was their agent.

Both sides had accident reconstruction experts to support their liability claims and demonstrate to the jury how the accident may have taken place. The purpose of these experts is to give the jury an understanding of who was at fault for the accident. After deliberation the jury decided that the defendant truck driver was 60% liable and that Hancock was 40% liable for the accident.

Continue reading "Truck Accident Leaves Illinois Teens Dead" »